Repair or replace?
Enter the numbers. The calculator applies the standard 50% rule and shows its work.
Typical lifespans shown are general industry averages; actual lifespan varies by brand, use, and maintenance. The 50% rule is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee.
The 50 percent rule
When the repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new appliance, replacement is usually the better value. That is the rule this calculator applies, plus one more factor: age. A repair can be cheap and still be the wrong call if the appliance is near the end of its life, and an expensive repair can be right if the appliance has years left. The calculator weighs both. Enter the appliance type, its age, the repair quote, and the cost of a new one, and it shows its work: the repair as a share of new, the age as a share of typical lifespan, and the years of expected life left.
The verdicts work like this. REPLACE when the repair costs more than half the price of new and the appliance is already past half its typical life. REPAIR when the repair costs less than half the price of new and the appliance is under 75 percent of its typical life. Anything in between is a judgment call, and the calculator says so: little life left, or a second repair in a year, points to replace, while a single first repair with years left points to repair.
Typical lifespans
Typical lifespans shown are general industry averages. Actual lifespan varies by brand, use, and maintenance.
| Appliance | Typical lifespan |
|---|---|
| Refrigerator | 13 years |
| Washer | 10 years |
| Dryer | 13 years |
| Dishwasher | 9 years |
| Furnace | 15 years |
| Water heater | 10 years |
| Oven / Range | 15 years |
| Garage door opener | 10 years |
An example with real numbers
A dishwasher control board costs $240 to $500, and a new standard dishwasher costs $400 to $1,800 installed (Home Repair Cost Index, November 2026). On a $400 machine, that repair is more than half the price of new, so a dishwasher past 4 or 5 years, half its 9-year typical life, points to replace. On a $1,800 machine, the same repair is under a third of new, so repair is usually right. The rule only works with both numbers in front of you, so get the repair total in writing and check the replacement price before you decide, not after.
What the rule does not cover
Energy bills, for one. A new appliance can cost less to run than the one it replaces, and that saving does not show up in a repair quote. Neither does the hassle of a second breakdown six months later. The 50 percent rule is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee. Use it to frame the decision, then weigh the running costs and the reliability of the machine you actually own.
When is a repair not worth doing?
When the repair costs more than half the price of a comparable new appliance. The guides on this site give the same advice for dishwashers, dryers, washers, and fridges: get the repair total in writing, compare it to the replacement price, and decide with both numbers in front of you. An older appliance that needs two big repairs at once is usually telling you something.
Does the age of the appliance matter as much as the price?
Yes. The calculator weighs both. A repair under half the price of new is still the wrong call if the appliance is past 75 percent of its typical life with little expected life left. A dishwasher typically lasts 9 years, a washer 10, a fridge 13, and a furnace 15, as general industry averages.
What counts as the replacement cost?
The price of a comparable new appliance, installed. Use the same size and class as the one you own, not the cheapest model or the top of the range. The Cost Index lists installed replacement prices where the guides give them, including $400 to $1,800 for a standard dishwasher and $700 to $1,600 for a standard range.
What if the calculator says judgment call?
Two factors decide it: how much expected life is left, and the repair as a share of new. Little life left, or a second repair in a year, points to replace. A single first repair with years left points to repair. Get the repair total in writing before you decide.